Comparison of natural and chemical herbicides for weed management in Veracruz, Mexico

Valentín Alberto Esqueda-Esquivel, Sergio Uribe-Gómez, Rigoberto Zetina-Lezama, Marco Antonio Reynolds-Chávez, Nain Peralta-Antonio

Abstract


Background. Synthetic herbicides have reduced crop yield losses due to competition with weeds. However, their excessive use has led to the development of resistant ecotypes and damage to health and the environment. In response, countries such as Mexico have issued decrees to reduce their use, prompting the search for alternatives to glyphosate. Objective. To determine the efficacy of five natural and three synthetic herbicides for arvenses control in Veracruz, Mexico. Methodology. At INIFAP's Cotaxtla Experimental site, Zecatryn, Sec Natural, Herbitech, Kill-Herbs, and Vinecide were evaluated, as well as glyphosate, paraquat, and ammonium glufosinate, using commercial doses. A randomized block design with four replicates was used. Results. Weed control was achieved between 80 and 90% with glyphosate and Sec Natural up to 40 days after application (DAA), with similar results to those of Herbitech, Kill-Herbs, and ammonium glufosinate (70-80%). Paraquat achieved 50%, while Zecatryn recorded less than 15%. Implications. Some of the natural herbicides evaluated could be used as alternatives to glyphosate. Conclusions. Glyphosate showed higher effectiveness, with control greater than 80% at 70 DAA. Sec Natural, Herbitech, and Kill-Herbs had good to moderate efficiency up to 40 DAA, positioning them as viable bioherbicide options in an integrated weed control approach.

Keywords


Baltimora recta; Ixophorus unisetus; Parthenium hysterophorus; Cyperus rotundus.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Ahuja, M., Kumar, L., Kumar, K., Shingatgeri, V. M. and Kumar, S. 2024. Glyphosate: a review on its widespread prevalenceand occurrence across various systems. Environmental Sciences: Advances 3(7), pp. 1030-1038. https://doi.org/10.1039/d4va00085d

Alvarado, A., Carrera, D. and Yance, G., 2016. Estudio del impacto en el control natural de malezas a partir del vinagre. Revista Caribeña de Ciencias Sociales, [en línea] disponible en http://www.eumed.net/rev/caribe/2016/12/vinagre.html [consulta: 7 abril 2025].

Andreotti, G., Koutros, S., Hofmann, J.N., Sandler, D.P., Lubin, J.H., Lynch, C.F., Lerro, C.C., De Roos, A.J., Parks, C.G., Alavanja, M.C., Silverman, D.T. and Freeman, L.E.B., 2018. Glyphosate use and cancer incidence in the agricultural health study. Journal of the National Cancer Institute, 110(5), pp. 509-516. https://doi.org/10.1093/jnci/djx233

Arispe-Vázquez, J.L., Cadena-Zamudio, D.A., Tamayo Esquer, L.M., Noriega-Cantú, D.H., Toledo-Aguilar, R., Felipe-Victoriano, M., Barrón-Bravo, O.G., Reveles-Hernández, M., Ramírez-Sánchez, S.E. and Espinoza-Ahumada, C.A., 2023. A review of the current panorama of glyphosate resistance among weeds in Mexico and the rest of the world. Agro Productividad, 16(7), pp. 135-149. https://doi.org/10.32854/agrop. v16i7.2618

Asghar, M., Baig, M.M.Q., Latif, M.T. and Hussain, M., 2021. Evaluation of the effect of different herbicides for the control of parthenium weed. Turkey Journal of Weed Science, 24(1), pp. 19-28. [en línea] disponible en https://dergipark.org.tr/en/download/article-file/1121932 [consulta: 7 abril 2025].

Beckie, H.J., Flower, K.C. and Ashworth, M.B., 2020, Farming without glyphosate? Plants, 9(1), 96. https://doi.org/10.3390/plants9010096

Cantrell, C.L., Dayan, F.E. and Duke, S.O., 2012. Natural products as sources for new pesticides. Journal of Natural Products, 75(6), pp.1231-1242. https://doi.org/10.1021/np300024u

Colbach, N., Petit, S., Chauvel, B., Deytieux, V., Lechenet. M., Munier-Jolain, N. and Cordeu, S. 2020. The pitfalls of relating weed, herbicide use, and crop yield; don’ fall into the trap! A critical review. Frontiers in Agronomy, 2, pp. 615470. https://doi.org/10.3389/fagro.2020.615470

Cruz-Ortiz, L. and Flores-Méndez, M., 2021. Avances en el desarrollo de nuevos herbicidas biológicos a partir de extractos vegetales fitotóxicos aplicados in vitro. Informador Técnico, 86(1), pp. 34-45. https://doi.org/10.23850/22565035.3648

Daniel Gómez, A.E. and Jiménez Estrada, S.N., 2024. Formulación de nanoherbicidas a partir de D-Limoneno para su evaluación en malezas bajo invernadero. Tesis de licenciatura no publicada. Tlajomulco de Zúñiga, Jal., Mexico: Instituto Tecnológico de Tlajomulco.

Dayan, F.E., Cantrell, C.L. and Duke, S.O., 2009. Natural products in crop protection. Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry, 17(12), pp. 4022-4034. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bmc.2009.01.046

Dayan, F.E. and Duke, S.O., 2014. Natural compounds as next-generation herbicides. Plant Physiology, 166(3), pp. 1090-1105. https://doi.org/10.1104/pp.114.239061

Domínguez-Valenzuela, J.A., Gherekhloo, J., Fernández-Moreno, P.T., Cruz-Hipólito, H.E., Alcántara-de la Cruz, R., Sánchez-González, E. and De Prado, R., 2017. First confirmation and characterization of target and non-target site resistance to glyphosate in Palmer amaranth (Amaranthus palmeri) from Mexico. Plant Physiology and Biochemistry, 115, pp. 212-218. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.plaphy.2017.03.022

Espinosa-Ramírez, M. and Cisneros-López, M.E., 2022. Herbicidas orgánicos alternativa al glifosato para el control de maleza en presiembra en el norte de Tamaulipas. Avances en Investigación Agropecuaria, 26, pp. 13-14. https://doi.org/10.53897/RevAIA.22.26.16

Esqueda, E.V.A., Enríquez, Q.J.F. and Matilde, H.C., 2022. Alternativas al glifosato para el control de malezas en cítricos en el estado de Veracruz: Resultados en 2021. In: J.C. Delgado-Castillo, E. Rosales-Robles y J.C. Delgado-Tinoco. (eds.). Memorias del XLIII Congreso Nacional de la Ciencia de la Maleza. Celebrado el 22-24 noviembre 2022 (virtual). Sociedad Mexicana de la Ciencia de la Maleza, 97-106.

Esqueda, E.V.A., Enríquez, Q.J.F., Matilde, H.C. and Díaz, Z.U.A., 2021. Alternativas al glifosato para el control de malezas en limón persa en el estado de Veracruz. In: J.C. Delgado-Castillo, E. Rosales-Robles y J.C. Delgado-Tinoco. (eds.). Memorias del XLII Congreso Nacional de la Ciencia de la Maleza. Celebrado el 23-25 noviembre 2021 (virtual). Sociedad Mexicana de la Ciencia de la Maleza, pp. 228-235.

Esqueda-Esquivel, V.A., Tosquy-Valle, O.H., Ramírez-Vera, A.R. and Andrés-Meza. P., 2025. Effectiveness of fomesafen alone and its mixtures for weed control in bean crops. Agro Productividad, 18(2), pp. 125-134. https://doi.org/10.32854/agrop.v18i2.3250

Esqueda-Esquivel, V.A., Uresti-Durán, D. and Hernández-Aragón, L., 2015. Alternativas al fenoxaprop-etil para el control del zacate Johnson Sorghum halepense (L.) Pers. en arroz de riego. Ecosistemas y Recursos Agropecuarios, 2(6), pp. 317-325. http://dx.doi.org/10.19136/era.a2n6.294

Fonteyne, S., Leal Gonzalez, A. J., Osorio Alcalá, L., Villa Alcántara, J., Santos Rodriguez, C., Núñez Peñaloza, O., Ovando Galdámez, J. R., Singh, R. G. and Verhulst, N. 2022. Weed management and tillage effect on rainfed maize production in three agro-ecologies in Mexico. Weed Research, 62, pp. 224-239. https://doi.org/10.1111/wre.12530

Forsburg, F. 2007. Vinegar as an herbicide in organic garlic production. [en línea] disponible en https://projects.sare.org/media/pdf/8/7/9/879405fne03-461-final-report.pdf [consulta: 9 abril 2025].

Frans, R.E., Talbert, R., Marx, D. and Crowley, H., 1986. Experimental design and techniques for measuring and analyzing plant responses to weed control practices. In: N. D. Camper, ed. Research Methods in Weed Science. Southern Weed Science Society. pp. 29-46.

García, M.K. and Orozco, S.M., 2021. Efectos de herbicidas agroecológicos para el control de malezas en limón mexicano (Citrus aurantifolia) en Tecomán, Colima. In: J.C. Delgado-Castillo, E. Rosales-Robles y J.C. Delgado-Tinoco (eds.). Memorias del XLII Congreso Nacional de la Ciencia de la Maleza. Celebrado el 23-25 noviembre 2021 (virtual). Sociedad Mexicana de la Ciencia de la Maleza, 122-129.

Gharde, Y., Singh, P.K., Dubey, R.P. and Gupta, P.K., 2018. Assessment of yield and economic losses in agriculture due to weeds in India. Crop Protection, 107, pp. 12-18. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cropro.2018.01.007

Hasan, M., Ahmad-Hamdani, M.S., Rosli, A.M. and Hamdan, H., 2021. Bioherbicides: an eco-friendly tool for sustainable weed management. Plants, 10(6), pp. 1212. https://doi.org/10.3390/plants10061212

Heap, I. 2025. The International Herbicide-Resistant Weed Database. [en línea] disponible en http://weedscience.org/Pages/filter.aspx [consulta: 9 abril 2025].

Hernández, M.R., Rosales, R.E., Espinosa, R.M. and Cisneros, L.M.E., 2021. Efectividad de herbicidas alternativos a glifosato en el control de malezas en el norte de Tamaulipas. In: J.C. Delgado-Castillo, E. Rosales-Robles y J.C. Delgado-Tinoco (eds.). Memorias del XLII Congreso Nacional de la Ciencia de la Maleza. Celebrado el 23-25 noviembre 2021 (virtual). Sociedad Mexicana de la Ciencia de la Maleza, 259-266.

Horvath, D.P., Clay, S.A., Swanton, C.J. Anderson, J.V. and Chao, W.S., 2023. Weed-induced crop yield loss: a new paradigm and new challenges. Trends in Plant Science, 28(5), pp. 567-582. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tplants.2022.12.014

Kanatas, P., Antonopoulos, N., Gazoulis. I. and Travlos, I. S. 2021. Screening glyphosate-alternative weed control options in important perennial crops. Weed Science 69(6), pp. 704-718. https://doi.org/10.1017/wsc.2021.55

Loddo, D., McElroy, J.S. and Giannini, V., 2021. Problems and perspectives in weed management. Italian Journal of Agronomy, 16(4), 1854. https://doi.org/10.4081/ija.2021.1854

Low, T., 2020. Glyphosate: a chemical to understand. Invasive Species Council. [en línea] disponible en https://invasives.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Glyphosate-A-Chemical-to-Understand.pdf [consulta: 10 abril 2025].

Medina-Cázares, T., Solís-Moya, E. Grageda-Cabrera, O.A. and González-Figueroa, S.S., 2024. Narrow and broadleaf weed control in wheat. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Agrícolas, 5(6), pp.e3105. https://doi.org/10.29312/remexca.v15i6.3105

Merlo-Reyes, A., Baduel, C., Duwig, C. and Ramírez, M.I., 2024. Risk assessment of pesticides used in the eastern avocado belt of Michoacan, Mexico: A survey and water monitoring approach. Science of The Total Environment, 916, pp.170288. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2024.170288

Miranda-Arámbula, M., Reyes-Chilpa, R. and Anaya, L.A.L., 2021. Phytotoxic activity of aqueous extracts of ruderal plants and its potential application to tomato crop. Botanical Sciences, 99(3), pp. 487-498. https://doi.org/10.17129/botsci.2727

Monroy-Sais, A.S., Astier, M., Wies, G., Pavesi, R., Mascorro-de Loera, D. and García-Barrios, L., 2022. Exploring the complexity of smallholders’ intense use of glyphosate in maize crops from South Mexico: Remarks for an ongoing agroecological transition. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 6, pp.908779. https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2022.908779

Morales-Payan, J.P., Charudattan, R. and Stall, W.M., 2005. Fungi for biological control of weedy cyperaceae, with emphasis on purple and yellow nutsedges (Cyperus rotundus and C. esculentus). Pest Management, 16(4), pp.148-155. https://doi.org/10.1564/16aug02.

Orozco, S.M. and García, M.K., 2024. Evaluación de alternativas químicas y orgánicas al herbicida glifosato para el control de maleza en el cultivo de banano. Acrobat Revista de Tecnología y Ciencia, 1(1), pp.67, https://doi.org/10.62498/ARTC.2467

Palma-Bautista, C., Gherekhloo, J., Domínguez-Martínez, P.A., Domínguez-Valenzuela, J. A., Cruz-Hipólito, H.E., Alcántara- de la Cruz, R., Rojano-Delgado, A.M. and De Prado, R., 2019. Characterization of three glyphosate resistant Parthenium hysterophorus populations collected in citrus groves from Mexico. Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology, 155, pp. 1-7. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pestbp.2018.11.002

Pérez-Vázquez, A., Fernández-Peña, M.L., Castañeda-Chávez, M.R. and Díaz-Rivera, P., 2024. Glifosato: riesgo o amenaza para la salud humana y la vida silvestre. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Agrícolas, 15(5), e3342. https://doi.org/10.29312/remexca.v15i5.3342

Quintero-Pertúz, I. and Carbonó-De la Hoz, E., 2016. Panorama del manejo de malezas en cultivos de banano en el departamento del Magdalena, Colombia. Revista Colombiana de Ciencias Hortícolas, 9 (2), pp. 329-340. https://doi.org/10.17584/rcch.2015v9i2.4188

Rahayuningsih, S. and Supriadi, S., 2014. Herbicidal efficacy of acetic acid and citric acid base on broad leaf weeds of medicinal crops fields. Buletin Penelitian Tanaman Rempah dan Obat, 25(2), pp. 137-143. https://doi.org/10.21082/bullittro.v25n2

Rebolledo, M.L., Rebolledo, M.A., Montiel, V.G., López, V.M.E., Peralta, A.N., Rebolledo, G.R.L. and Uriza, Á.D.E., 2019. Herbicidas convencionales y orgánicos para control de malezas en el cultivo de piña. In: Avances en Investigación Agrícola, Pecuaria, Forestal, Acuícola, Pesquería, Desarrollo Rural, Transferencia de Tecnología, Biotecnología, Ambiente, Recursos naturales y Cambio climático. Vinay, V.J.C., Esqueda, E.V.A., Tosquy, V.O.H., Zetina, L.R., Ríos, U.A., Vázquez, H.M.V, Del Angel, P.A.L. y Perdomo, M.C. (comps.). Medellín, Ver., Mexico: Instituto Nacional de Investigaciones Forestales, Agrícolas y Pecuarias, 201-210.

Rocha-Munive, M.G., Soberón, M., Castañeda, S., Niaves, E., Scheinvar, E., Eguiarte, L.E., Mota-Sánchez, D., Rosales-Robles, E., Nava-Camberos, U., Martínez-Carrillo, J.L., Blanco, C.A., Bravo, A. and Souza, V., 2018. Evaluation of the impact of genetically modified cotton after 20 years of cultivation in Mexico. Frontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 6, pp.82. https://doi.org/10.3389/fbioe.2018.00082

Rojas, G.M. and Gámez, G.H., 2002. Herbicidas de origen natural. Ciencia UANL, 5(2), pp.160-164. [en línea] disponible en https://www.redalyc.org/pdf/402/40250204.pdf [consulta: 9 abril 2025].

SAS Institute Inc. 2015. SAS/STAT 9.4: User's Guide. Cary, NC: SAS Institute Inc.

SEGOB (Secretaría de Gobernación). 2020. Diario Oficial de la Federación. Secretaría de Gobernación. [en línea] disponible en http://www.dof.gob.mx/nota_detalle.php?codigo=5609365&fecha=31/12/2020 [consulta: 8 abril 2025].

SEGOB (Secretaría de Gobernación). 2022. Diario Oficial de la Federación. Secretaría de Gobernación. [en línea] disponible en https://www.dof.gob.mx/nota_detalle.php?codigo=5679405&fecha=13/02/2023#gsc.tab=0 [consulta: 8 abril 2025].

Schwentesius-Rindermann, R., Dámaso-Lara, N. and Hernández-Vázquez, B., 2024. Comparación de bioherbicidas y herbicidas sintéticos en San Juan Tezontla, Texcoco de Mora, Mexico. In: H.E. Alvarado-Raya, J. Martínez-Solís y N. Magaña-Lira. (eds.). Memorias del XII Congreso Internacional y XXVI Congreso Nacional de Ciencias Agronómicas. Celebrados el 23-26 abril 2024. Universidad Autónoma Chapingo, 259-260.

Soto, M., Gama, L. and Gómez, M., 2001. Los climas cálidos subhúmedos del estado de Veracruz, Mexico. Foresta Veracruzana, 3(2), pp. 31-40.

Souza, B.V.M. de, Ferreira, P.J.L., Ribeiro, G.D., Carvalho, L.M.F., Rodrigues, C.G., Gonçalves, A.H. and Quinute, T.P.V.V., 2020. Herbicides of biological origin: a review. The Journal of Horticultural Science and Biotechnology, 96(3), pp. 288-293. https://doi.org/10.1080/14620316.2020.1846465

Tejeda-Sartorius, O. and Rodríguez-González, M.T., 2008. Inhibidores de germinación y crecimiento de maleza y hortalizas, en residuos de amaranto (Amaranthus hypochondriacus L.). Agrociencia, 42(4), pp. 415-423.

Torretta, V., Katsoyiannis, I.A., Viotti, P. and. Rada, E.C., 2018. Critical review of the effects of glyphosate exposure to the environment and humans through the food supply chain. Sustainability, 10(4), 950. https://doi.org/10.3390/su10040950

Tse-Seng, G., Nasarrudin, A. R. M., Masilamany, D., Chai, K., Byung-Woo, L., Arifin, M. F. and Sang-Sun, L., 2022. Effect of surfactant and different spray volumes on the efficacy of acetic acid based natural herbicide for controlling Imperata cylindrica and Sporobolus indicus. Plant Omics Journal, 15(01), pp. 1-5. http://doi.org/10.21475/POJ.15.01.22.p3371

Urrutia, C.A.L. and García, B.L.E., (Coords.). 2024. Manejo Ecológico Integral de Arvenses en Mexico (MEIA). Compilado de Gacetas 1 a 27. [en línea] disponible en. https://secihti.mx/wp-content/uploads/publicaciones_conacyt/boletines_tematicos/Gaceta_MEIA_imprenta_1-27.pdf [consulta: 10 abril 2025].

Vibrans, H. (ed.) 2009. Malezas de Mexico. [en línea] disponible en https://www.conabio.gob.mx/malezasde mexico/2inicio/home-malezas-mexico.htm [consulta: 17 septiembre 2025].

Webber III, C.L., White Jr., P.M., Shrefler, J.W. and Spaunhorst, D.J., 2018. Impact of acetic acid concentration, application volume, and adjuvants on weed control efficacy. Journal of Agricultural Science, 10(8), pp. 1-1. https://doi.org/10.5539/jas.v10n8p1

Wen-Tien, T., 2013. A review on environmental exposure and health risks of herbicide paraquat. Toxicological and Environmental Chemistry, 95(2), pp. 197-206. https://doi.org/10.1080/02772248.2012.761999

WFO (The Worls Flora OnLine). 2025. Baltimora recta L. [en línea] disponible en http://www.worldfloraonline.org/taxon/wfo-0000036140 [consulta: 17 septiembre 2025].

Wibawa, W., Mohayidin, M.G., Mohamad, R.B., Juraimi, A.S. and Omar, D., 2010. Efficacy and cost-effectiveness of three broad-spectrum herbicides to control weeds in immature oil palm plantation. Pertanika Journal of Tropical Agricultural Science, 33(2), pp. 233-241.




URN: http://www.revista.ccba.uady.mx/urn:ISSN:1870-0462-tsaes.v28i3.64479

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.56369/tsaes.6447

Bookmark and Share


Copyright (c) 2025 SERGIO URIBE-GÓMEZ, VALENTIN ALBERTO ESQUEDA-ESQUIVEL, RIGOBERTO ZETINA-LEZAMA, MARCO ANTONIO REYNOLDS-CHAVEZ, NAIN PERALTA-ANTONIO

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.